Tuesday, November 08, 2011

Why Obama can't be compared to FDR

Another great post from Ezra Klein:
In “Reaching for a New Deal,” Theda Skocpol and Lawrence Jacobs recall with bemusement the sepia-tinged excitement that greeted Obama’s victory in 2008. What the FDR-obsessed pundits missed, the two political scientists say, was that “the timing, nature, and severity” of the economic crises the two presidents faced were very different.
Franklin D. Roosevelt won the presidency in 1932, three years into the Great Depression. The unemployment rate that year was 23.6 percent. Obama won the presidency in 2008, mere months into the financial crisis; unemployment was at 6.8 percent. Consequently, the two presidents faced political systems prepared to do very different things.
In his new book, “The New Deal: A Modern History,” Michael Hiltzik makes clear that though FDR was an unusually energetic and ambitious president, he was paired with an unusually energetic and ambitious Congress.
Take the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., which ended traditional bank runs by insuring commercial bank deposits. FDR opposed it. He believed that “the weak banks will pull down the strong.” But senators from rural states represented those small, weak banks. Deposit insurance was part of the price they exacted to pass the Glass-Steagall banking law. “You will have to come to a deposit guarantee eventually, Cap’n,” Roosevelt’s vice president, John Nance Garner, told him. He did — but only because Congress forced him into it.
This happened again and again throughout the New Deal. FDR wanted to go far. But Congress often wanted to go further — occasionally over the president’s objections.
Read the whole thing.

Saturday, November 05, 2011

The Problem is Political

Ezra Klein, to whom tcnorris has provided a link for a long time, has written an excellent summary of why a bad economy has plagued Barack Obama in the form of a disparaging book review about Ron Suskind's Confidence Men.

Suskind did not get the story right at all, but this summary by Klein does:
It is easy to tell the story of what the White House did wrong in its response to the financial crisis: it underestimated it. It had good reason to underestimate it, of course. Almost everyone was underestimating it. In the fourth quarter of 2008, when Obama’s economic team was meeting in Chicago to map out their policies, the Bureau of Economic Accounts thought the economy was contracting at a rate of 3.8 percent per year. It wouldn’t be until this year that we learned the economy was really contracting at a rate of 9 percent. And it wasn’t just the BEA. The Federal Reserve has been continuously overoptimistic. So have the leading private forecasting firms, like Macroeconomic Advisers and Moody’s Analytics. And so have Wall Street banks like Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan.
The observers who got it right were the ones who could tell a story that didn’t rely on the early data. Kenneth Rogoff and Carmen Reinhart, who would publish This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, their epic history of financial crises, in late 2009, saw that the recovery would be slow and tough. Economists like Paul Krugman and Joseph Stiglitz, who were more knowledgeable about the struggles over recession in Japan and had their own Keynesian understanding of financial panics, were also suitably pessimistic.
But early mistakes can be corrected. If the initial stimulus is too small, you make it bigger. If your housing policies are too modest, you toughen them up. If the private sector sheds jobs and long-term unemployment becomes a problem, you begin hiring workers directly.
Or so goes the theory. The reality is more troubling. The initial stimulus was too small, but there’s no plausible case that Congress would have been willing to make it much bigger just because the Obama administration had a theory that the financial crisis would lead to a worse recession than most forecasters expected. The trouble was that attacking a financial crisis with a too-small stimulus was a bit like attacking pneumonia with too-few antibiotics: you feel better for awhile, and then it comes back. And this time, it’s harder to kill.
The problem is political. Having very publicly passed a very big policy that you promised would revive the economy, the country blames you when the economy does not, in fact, revive. Your policies are discredited and your opponents are emboldened. You lose seats in the next election and your leverage over lawmakers. So you can’t, with any prospect of success, go back to the well and ask for a bigger stimulus or more money to buy up bad mortgages. And then, when the economy gets worse, you’re simultaneously in charge and out of options. You came to Washington promising change and now you’re begging for patience. It’s a crummy situation, and there’s no combination of policy proposals or speeches that can get you out of it. But this is the vise that has tightened around Barack Obama’s presidency.
It seems to me that even those who got it right such as Krugman probably underestimated how much stimulus was actually needed (although he foresaw the political consequences). The Obama stimulus was $700 billion and Krugman and others spoke of 1.3 billion over two years.  As Klein notes revisions to the data made only this year tell us the downturn was much worse than suspected at the time.

We still need lots of stimulus, but the blame for not doing anything now squarely and unequivocally belongs with the Republicans and the austerity class, something that the media in particular, has had trouble figuring out.

More needs to be done by government in the form of public spending in the U.S., Europe and Canada. The mania for deficit cutting and balanced budgets is insane. It cannot be said often enough or loudly enough: we must not worry about deficits while the problem is deflation and unemployment.

Sunday, October 23, 2011

Persistent Unemployment & the Austerity Class

Over the longer run I remain an economic optimist, but the North American economy is being dragged down by an "Austerity Class" that dominates political and media discourse preventing the adoption of the Keynsian policies needed to break out of our current economic malaise. Ari Berman has written an excellent summary of its influence in the Nation, that I discovered courtesy of Economist's View:
...a central paradox in American politics over the past two years: how, in the midst of a massive unemployment crisis—when it’s painfully obvious that not enough jobs are being created and the public overwhelmingly wants policy-makers to focus on creating them—did the deficit emerge as the most pressing issue in the country? And why, when the global evidence clearly indicates that austerity measures will raise unemployment and hinder, not accelerate, growth, do advocates of austerity retain such distinction today?

An explanation can be found in the prominence of an influential and aggressive austerity class—an allegedly centrist coalition of politicians, wonks and pundits who are considered indisputably wise custodians of US economic policy. These “very serious people,” as New York Times columnist Paul Krugman wryly dubs them, have achieved what University of California, Berkeley, economist Brad DeLong calls “intellectual hegemony over the course of the debate in Washington, from 2009 until today.”

Its members include Wall Street titans like Pete Peterson and Robert Rubin; deficit-hawk groups like the CRFB, the Concord Coalition, the Hamilton Project, the Committee for Economic Development, Third Way and the Bipartisan Policy Center; budget wonks like Peter Orszag, Alice Rivlin, David Walker and Douglas Holtz-Eakin; red state Democrats in Congress like Mark Warner and Kent Conrad, the bipartisan “Gang of Six” and what’s left of the Blue Dog Coalition; influential pundits like Tom Friedman and David Brooks of the New York Times, Niall Ferguson and the Washington Post editorial page; and a parade of blue ribbon commissions, most notably Bowles-Simpson, whose members formed the all-star team of the austerity class.

The austerity class testifies frequently before Congress, is quoted constantly in the media by sympathetic journalists and influences policy-makers and elites at the highest levels of power. They manufacture a center-right consensus by determining the parameters of acceptable debate and policy priorities, deciding who is and is not considered a respectable voice on fiscal matters. The “balanced” solutions they advocate are often wildly out of step with public opinion and reputable economic policy, yet their influence endures, thanks to an abundance of money, the ear of the media, the anti-Keynesian bias of supply-side economics and a political system consistently skewed to favor Wall Street over Main Street.

Taken together, the various strands of the austerity class form a reinforcing web that is difficult to break. Its think tanks and wonks produce a relentless stream of disturbing statistics warning of skyrocketing debt and looming bankruptcy, which in turn is trumpeted by politicians and the press and internalized by the public. Thus forms what Washington Post blogger Greg Sargent calls a Beltway Deficit Feedback Loop, wherein the hypothetical possibility of a US debt crisis somewhere in the future takes precedence over the very real jobs crisis now.

See the rest of the article here.

Part of what permits this oppressive admosphere to flourish is a journalism that refuses to acknowledge the most obvious of facts.  This phenomenon was recently tackled by James Fallows, a blogger with the Atlantic and former Jimmy Carter speech writer, who took on the dishonest practices of Washington journalism that have facilitated the Republicans' deliberate obstruction of the Democratic majority Senate, using the example of Obama's jobs bill, an initiative at odds with the views of the austerity class.

The link above was to his original post but he followed it up here, here, here, here, and here.

Sunday, October 09, 2011

Ontario election polls postscript

The Ontario election produced a minority, or bare majority if the legislature selects an opposition member to be speaker, who is then obligated to vote with the government in the event of tied vote.

Overall, the polls were fairly close to the actual result. The day after analysis in the Globe, in TC's view, was somewhat muddled on this point.

The table below illustrates how the pollsters performed.  It is ranked by the sum of the errors with respect to the PCs, Liberals and NDP (the Top Three column). The All column adds in the error for Greens and others:





Liberal
PC
N.D.P.
GP
Other
Total Error

Election Result
Oct. 6, 2011
37.62
35.40
22.70
2.90
1.30
All
Top 3
Oct. 5, 2011
Forum Research
Oct. 4-5
-0.62
-2.40
0.30
0.10
-0.30
3.72
3.32
Oct. 4, 2011
Abacus Data
Oct. 3-4
-0.62
-1.40
1.30
1.10
-0.30
4.72
3.32
Oct. 5, 2011
EKOS
Oct. 3-5
0.98
-1.40
-1.60
2.40
-0.30
6.68
3.98
Oct. 4, 2011
Nanos Research
Oct 1-3
0.08
-2.20
3.10
0.50
-1.30
7.18
5.38
Oct. 5, 2011
Angus Reid*
Oct. 4-5
-0.62
-2.40
3.30
0.10
-0.30
6.72
6.32
Oct. 4, 2011
Angus Reid*
Oct. 3-4
-4.62
0.60
3.30
2.10
-1.30
11.92
8.52
Oct. 4, 2011
Ipsos Reid
Sept 30-Oct 3
3.38
-4.40
2.30
0.10
-0.30
10.48
10.08

Ipsos, which is at the bottom of this list, had the most accurate poll in the federal election.  Given the inherent error in polling one should be very cautious in concluding which polling firm is 'better' than others.

However, there is an asterisk beside Angus Reid as they delivered two 'final' polls in less than a day leading to this account in the Globe after the election:
Ipsos Reid said the Liberals would receive 41 per cent among decided voters, the Tories 31 per cent and the NDP 25 per cent.
That same day, the polling firm Angus Reid announced in a press release, titled “Tories Edging Liberals But Ontario Race Could Turn in Final Hours.” that an online survey it conducted from Monday to Tuesday morning showed the Tories were at 36 per cent and the Liberals at 33 per cent.

“The Progressive Conservative Party has recovered some grounds,” the firm said of its survey conducted for the Toronto Star.

The Star published the results, saying it was the final major poll of the campaign.

But later that day, Angus Reid began to conduct another online poll, which yielded very different results.

“We wanted to track the election right to the last minute so we want back in the field Tuesday afternoon,” Angus Reid managing director Jaideep Mukerji said in an interview.

“There was volatility among Ontarians . . . We knew it was going to a very tight race.”

The later poll ,which wasn’t commissioned by the Star but conducted on Angus Reid’s own account, Mr. Mukerji said, predicted the Liberals would get 37 per cent, the Conservatives 33 per cent and the NDP 26 per cent.

“We’re happy we caught that shift,” Mr. Mukerji said. “There were some Liberals at the last minute who got cold feet about voting conservatives.”

The pollster who worked for The Globe and Mail and CTV, Nanos Research, however released similar numbers two days before Angus Reid’s final poll.

Federal election polls in Ontario
The polls on the provincial election were quite good overall. This was was not the case with the Ontario sub-samples on polls taken during the federal election. The average error in Ontario understated Conservative support by 6.1 percentage points while overstating all the others, the NDP by the 3.2 points the Liberals by 1.7 and the Greens by 1.1.  TC is still puzzled by the error in polling during the federal election although one can find some interesting discussion of this on Pundit's Guide.  Ekos pollster Frank Greaves is the only one who seriously addressed his own mistakes after the election.

TC observes that the average Conservative support from the beginning of the federal election to the approximate beginning of the NDP surge in Ontario was 41.8% (not too far from 44.4% they actually won) and thereafter it averaged 38.1%. However, I am not sure what that tells us other than perhaps the instability in preferences reflected in the shift had some impact on the measurement difficulties actually experienced.

Wednesday, October 05, 2011

Ontario likely headed for Liberal majority

There has been closing tick in this election to the McGuinty Liberals.  Eight polls released since Monday by five different firms yield an average of:

Liberal: 37.6 %
PC: 33.2 %
NDP: 24.7 %
Green: 4.0 %

And less than 1% for others. 

This gives the Liberals 58 seats, 29 for the PCs and 20 for the NDP - a Liberal majority.  A minimum of 54 is required for a majority, so uncertainty remains about the issue of majority/minority.  TC thinks the Liberals will certainly win the most seats. It will likely be a majority (the Liberals could win over 60 seats) but there is still some doubt on that score. 

In these circumstances the trend is your friend and the trend is to the McGuinty Liberals.

Sunday, October 02, 2011

How close is it in Ontario?

About as close as it could be. Here is the average of the four polls released in the last couple of days:

Liberal PC NDP Green
34.4 34.6 26.4 4.1

The outcome seems likely to depend on asymmetric shifts within the province. In some regions such as the Greater Toronto Area Liberal losses appear to be smaller than in other areas. Overall there will be many close races. A small movement over the next couple of days could shift the election from one party to another.  The average above would give us a Liberal minority based on the 2007 results. 

Saturday, October 01, 2011

NDP headed for win in Manitoba

The Friday moring headline in the Free Press said "NDP clinging to lead", but it is clearly enough to ensure victory in next Tuesday's provincial election for Mr. Selinger's party. The Probe numbers are at roughly the midpoint of the other two polls, an average of the three essentially replicates Probe's numbers.

TC does not have an estimate model based on the current boundaries, but if the Probe numbers are accurate the one notable change we can see now would be the loss to the Liberals of both their seats. The NDP would win a majority.  How large is difficult to determine.  TC's estimate is that the absolute lowest number of NDP seats would be 30 (the result that would occur if the PCs win every close race) but it will probably be greater than that.